📊 Weekly NQ Trade Desk Self-Grade
A compact self-audit of this week’s automated NQ calls. The system handled the early-week upside structure well, but was too slow to downgrade bullish bias as Friday’s selloff accelerated. Raw positioning details remain internal; positioning was checked as part of the process.
Journal coverage: 84 reports seen lifetime; 47 unique NQ reports evaluated in this weekly window; 175 graded horizon outcomes.
Horizon Performance
| Horizon | Graded | Directional Accuracy | Target Hit | Invalidation Hit | Avg MFE | Avg MAE | Assessment |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 30m | 44 | 47.7% | 40.9% | 22.7% | +34.2 pts | 48.4 pts | Mixed / noisy |
| 60m | 44 | 50.0% | 45.5% | 22.7% | +43.8 pts | 69.0 pts | Acceptable but weak edge |
| 120m | 44 | 50.0% | 50.0% | 22.7% | +64.8 pts | 117.5 pts | Best balanced horizon |
| 240m | 43 | 51.2% | 53.5% | 25.6% | +100.4 pts | 153.0 pts | Highest target capture |
Setup Types
| Type | Outcomes | Target Hit | Avg Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Best: Bull / stretched | 132 | 58.3% | 90.9 |
| Bear / balanced | 7 | 85.7% | 88.4 |
| Worst: Bull / balanced | 36 | 0.0% | 72.4 |
No-Trade Condition Quality
No explicit no-trade field exists in the journal. Using “balanced + weak edge / high reversal risk” as a proxy, the system did not abstain enough on Friday. Quality: Needs improvement.
Missing: formal no-trade labels, confidence score, stop distance, and R-multiple fields.
Data Completeness
Available: grade, bias, stretched flag, support/resistance hits, MFE/MAE, horizon moves. Missing: explicit setup taxonomy, R multiple, sizing, slippage, and trade execution outcomes. Pending: final Friday 240m windows.
What Worked
- Longer horizons captured more of the weekly structure.
- Early-week bullish/stretched calls were repeatedly rewarded.
- The late Friday bearish flip graded well on available 30m–120m windows.
What Failed
- Directional accuracy near coin-flip is not acceptable as a standalone edge.
- Friday bullish calls remained active through a fast regime break.
- Bull/balanced bucket produced zero target hits this week.
Adjustments for Next Week
- Add a volatility/regime-break circuit breaker after large VWAP deviations.
- Downgrade or no-trade bull/balanced setups until target-hit rate recovers.
- Require explicit stop distance and R-multiple logging for every setup.
- Score 120m/240m higher than 30m when horizons conflict.